Good or bad password?

[tsaint]

First, thanks in advance to any or all responders.. I'll read with interest the comments but probably not add anything to the discussion.
Also, hope it won't engender the controversy my last question caused!!
Q: Is "Remember to pay gas Aug 14" a good, as in secure, password? I know it's good as in useability because I can hide it in plain sight (eg google calendar)
Thanks
Tony

[mouser]

that's an excellent password (pass phrase).
theoretically would be improved if you mispelled a word or otherwise made it ungrammatical.

[wraith808]

obligatory link to xkcd

[Target]

the difficulty here is that everyone remembers 'correct horse battery staple' and probably always will, but most of us still can't remember our own passwords (or where we put our car keys...)

[wraith808]

the difficulty here is that everyone remembers 'correct horse battery staple' and probably always will, but most of us still can't remember our own passwords (or where we put our car keys...)

-Target (May 11, 2016, 09:42 PM)

Since I switched to a passphrase for some things, I remember those better, and it's natural.  I usually now try to actually make a phrase instead of just stringing words together.  One that I do quite a bit is make the password a question, and the password reminder the answer.

[4wd]

Q: Is "Remember to pay gas Aug 14" a good, as in secure, password?

-tsaint (May 11, 2016, 08:17 PM)

I'd add some non-alphanumeric characters, eg. Remember! Pay gas bill, 14/08.

You could also keep it as Aug 14 in plain sight, just remembering to switch it to 14/08. for when you need to enter password.

[wraith808]

Q: Is "Remember to pay gas Aug 14" a good, as in secure, password?

-tsaint (May 11, 2016, 08:17 PM)

I'd add some non-alphanumeric characters, eg. Remember! Pay gas bill, 14/08.

You could also keep it as Aug 14 in plain sight, just remembering to switch it to 14/08. for when you need to enter password.

-4wd (May 11, 2016, 10:43 PM)

Along those lines, instead of adding non-numeric, I've just replaced the spaces with another character, so that the words are delimited by that character.

[tsaint]

Thanks for good ideas. My REAL password actually involves part of a friend's car number plate, which she USED to own (how paranoid is that?)
 What's now making my head spin tho, is that without a priori knowledge, isn't my passPHRASE actually a passWORD? (I hear Baynes calling). I see on various sites, entropy levels are different.
And Mouser, without knowing brute force passphrase cracking methodology, would having the mis-spelling early in the "pass-phrase" improve things?
This is all academic really but I'm interested - I've taken all the suggestions onboard thanks.

[Stoic Joker]

My REAL password actually involves part of a friend's car number plate, which she USED to own (how paranoid is that?)

-tsaint (May 12, 2016, 03:18 AM)

She should probably be very paranoid about the creepy old guy that keeps memorizing her license plate number...

But seriously the key to pass phrases is that the words should be completely non sequitur, but mnemonically associated with something by you.

So if your favorite movie scene involved a duck on a bicycle in the rain, the pass phrase for it might be.

Ride Cloudy Mallard!

[tsaint]

Creepy, old part is right, but in my defence, it's only numberplate memorization standing between me and senility

[f0dder]

Is "Remember to pay gas Aug 14" a good passphrase? That depends a bit on your adversary. It's long, but all its components exists in dictionaries. Personally, I'd suggest adding some nonsense words - and not just go for obvious substitutions like S->$, E->3 and the likes, since bruteforcing tools handle those.

And use different passphrases for different accounts. Having a perfect, non-bruteforceable passphrase doesn't help you if you use it everywhere, and it turns out that one of those sites stores the password in plaintext or encrypted rather than (properly) hashed. Either use a password manager (protected with the memorizable passphrase) and generate long random strings for other sites, or (if you're afraid of getting the password database stolen and your passphrase keylogged), think up a couple of passphrases for different uses. Like sharing one for forums and other low-impact sites, but keeping separate passphrases for your bank, email accounts, facebook or whatever other high-risk sites.

And yes, facebook would be a high-risk site for normal people, since it can be used as a login mechanism several places, as well as for grabbing juicy information that can be used for social engineering attacks.

[mouser]

And use different passphrases for different accounts

This is an important point that people sometimes overlook.  You need to be using different passwords(passphrases) for different sites, so that a security lapse on one site does not blow all your site logins.
A good solution is to use a password manager to hold all your passwords so you don't have to remember them.

[Target]

mmmm, passwords....

Good or bad password?