Mini-Review of Cropper

[kyrathaba]

Basic Info

Cropper	Cropper
App URL	http://www.codeplex.....aspx?ReleaseId=2309
App Version Reviewed	1.9.2
Test System Specs	OS Name   Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition Version   5.1.2600 Service Pack 3 Build 2600 System Manufacturer   IBM System Type   X86-based PC Processor   x86 Family 6 Model 13 Stepping 8 GenuineIntel ~1728 Mhz Total Physical Memory   1,024.00 MB Available Physical Memory   490.24 MB Total Virtual Memory   2.00 GB Available Virtual Memory   1.96 GB Page File Space   2.38 GB
Supported OSes	WinXP and Vista (purports to work on 64-bit Vista; I have XP)
Support Methods	author's website: http://blogs.geekdoj...rticles/Cropper.aspx and web-form email: http://blogs.geekdoj...t/brian/contact.aspx
Upgrade Policy	Cropper is freeware
Trial Version Available?	N/A
Pricing Scheme	N/A
Reviewer Donation Link	Donate to kyrathaba, the *reviewer*
Screencast Video URL	If there is a demo or screencast of the app somewhere, post the url here. If there is a DC Screencast, post the link here.
Relationship btwn. Reviewer and Product	As the reviewer, I have no form of relationship with the author of this program whatsoever.

Intro:

Cropper is a screen-capture application written in C# that leverages the image processing functions from the System.Drawing and System.Drawing.Drawing2D namespaces of the .NET Framework.  It was written by Brian Scott as a programming exercise in C#, but has gained a fair degree of popularity through a succession of versions.  It is particularly well-suited to taking a series of captures of the same size. 




Who is this app designed for:

This application wasn't really targeted at a specific audience, although the author does point out that his program is particularly handy for cropping out sections of vector graphics files, such as those produced by Fireworks, without having to first flatten the files.  Now that is handy.  I also think it's fair to say that, although it might be the exception rather than the rule on this particular site, there are many people out there that are technology-challenged.  My father comes to mind (hi dad!)  For those individuals, less is more.  I'm making a generalization there, but it is true for at least those few friends and family members I've introduced to Cropper.


The Good


The transparent window makes it easy to see what area you're about to target with your screenshot.  The minimalist interface is sparse but clean and lightweight.  Perfect for simple work like taking screenshots of text and images for use in a help file on your most recent application.  You just double-click the Cropper form or press the Enter key, and whatever is overlaid by the Cropper window will be captured and stored in a folder that you have indicated.  You can configure Cropper to save the captured images in a variety of formats (BMP, PNG, JPG, AVI, and animated GIF), or hold the captured image in the Windows clipboard.



The needs improvement section


Cropper isn't perfect; it can't capture menus, cursors, and transparent windows.  Additionally, in using the program, I found that it doesn't always persist the settings I selected under "Options".  It's annoying to have to instruct it to save captures to the Cropper folder on my desktop -- when I've already specified that behavior a few days ago while using the program.  If I wanted the settings to return to default, I'd select it myself under "Options"!  Cropper purports to support emailing, but I found Screenshot Captor to do so smoothly, while Cropper gave me this unsightly error:



Why I think you should use this product


If you're wanting to quickly take a screenshot of a problem to send to a software vendor, this program is the ticket.  Or if you just need simple captures of the entire screen or a given window; but if you want or need more advanced features, such as drop-shadows, emailing images, etc., then I recommend Screenshot Captor. 

How does it compare to similar apps

Having only used three screenshot apps in my lifetime, I cannot provide a good comparison among a roundup of applications of this type.  Fortunately, there are many more experienced users of such apps who frequent this site, and perhaps this mini-review will spur feedback or a more in-depth review.  I will say that I use Cropper in producing screenshots for my Wink 2.0 C# tutorials, but that when I needed the drop-shadow to improve the appearance of the graphics on my DC Homepage, I turned to Screenshot Captor.


Conclusions

Overall, I like Cropper for its simplicity.  The interface is non-threatening, and as a person who feels easily threatened by powerful software, that appeals to me *grin*.  For the sorts of screen-grabs and region-captures I need when making my C# tutorials, it's the right simple tool for a simple task.  And, of course, as a fan of C#, I am proud to use a nifty freeware tool written in that .NET language.  For those whose image capturing needs are more substantive, or who like finer-grained control and greater options, I'd recommend Screenshot Captor as a more powerful alternative.


Links to other reviews of this application

ZDNet Review
Superwasp Review
SnapFiles Review
Softpedia Review

[mouser]

Very nice minireview
Seeing the Cropper context menu makes me think I really do need to add some more Send To features to Screenshot Captor.

[mzah8]

Nice mini-review!

I also used Cropper for a while, and it seemed pretty nifty. But there was a rather annoying problem I had with it... if I'm not mistaken, it only allowed a maximum width of less than a 1000 (I can't remember the specific number). I like to screenshot good/artistic website layouts for inspiration, and with Cropper I couldn't get the whole width of the layout.

I now use Screenshot Captor.

[exold]

I've used a few different screenshot-capture tools, and keep ending up back with Cropper. It has a number of plugins available these days, including plugins to allow you to capture images to an animated GIF, an AVI movie file, e-mail, flickr, OneNote, Amazon S3, or TinyPic. There is also a plugin that allows you to create a new Team Foundation Server work item with the captured image as an attachment, as well as one that gives you a countdown before capturing the screen (to allow setup). A few crashes aside, I've never had reason to complain about the functionality, and you can't beat the price .