6151
General Software Discussion / Re: General brainstorming for Note-taking software
« on: March 01, 2006, 12:16 AM »
OK, since I'm already thinking about it, I will begin to post some of my comments about Surfulater:
--Surfulater--
First of all, I read the blog you (nevf) wrote about Surfulater's future and everything, it was excellent. Now, most of my critique of Surfulater is hinging on the fact that the program will eventually become a full-fledged note-editing program. If not, that most, if not all, of my comments will be out of context and somewhat useless. I say this because I just don't see how I can use one program to capture a whole bunch of information, but then I can't add my personal notes about related items and separate items in the same program. Information is information and I would like it all to be in the same place. Okay, that being said...
Let me first start off by saying that I'm not a big fan of html/xml/java being used in standalone applications as it's core. However, it is done right in Surfulater as in A-book (which I reviewed earlier), so even though I don't prefer it, I'm okay with it when it is used in a creative and useful manner.
Part of what I don't like about Surfulater is that it is not yet ready for taking notes in an efficient manner. Sure it can capture anything from anywhere, but what if I just want to write a little paragraph or list? I am restricted by the handful of templates that are there (clipboard, contact, code snippet, etc...). And the templates are too bulky for me. I don't need all that big title, references, and large borders on the right side. I just want a blank area to type a little bit of text. So, that's one of the reasons why I wouldn't use the program at this point.
Anyway, I'm too tired to write anymore right now. But that is my complaint of Surfulater so far. It's just not a notetaking application yet, and I need that more so than it's spectacular ability to capture content. Let me put it this way, if you need to capture a lot of content without traditional notetaking (like you would in Keynote) than Surfulater is a great program for you, as in the case of jgiebeler, who sounds like he has to collect a whole lot of information from the web and other places. But if you're looking to organize a lot of simple text and little bits of information, you will be frustrated with Surfulater, it's just not meant for that yet.
So to bring this discussion all the way around to basic note-taking software, I will still assert that Mybase is closer to this goal than Surfulater. Capturing is only one part of notetaking, and it is an add-in (a luxury) at that. By that I mean that capturing is not the main goal of notetaking, so that shouldn't be the focus of this software genre. It could be the feature that makes one program better than the other, given that all else is equal, but it shouldn't be the primary focus. I think Surfulater's method of organizing it's articles with the multiple folders and (future) tags, is something that should be mirrored in a notetaking program also. That will bring this genre to the next level.
--Surfulater--
First of all, I read the blog you (nevf) wrote about Surfulater's future and everything, it was excellent. Now, most of my critique of Surfulater is hinging on the fact that the program will eventually become a full-fledged note-editing program. If not, that most, if not all, of my comments will be out of context and somewhat useless. I say this because I just don't see how I can use one program to capture a whole bunch of information, but then I can't add my personal notes about related items and separate items in the same program. Information is information and I would like it all to be in the same place. Okay, that being said...
Let me first start off by saying that I'm not a big fan of html/xml/java being used in standalone applications as it's core. However, it is done right in Surfulater as in A-book (which I reviewed earlier), so even though I don't prefer it, I'm okay with it when it is used in a creative and useful manner.
Part of what I don't like about Surfulater is that it is not yet ready for taking notes in an efficient manner. Sure it can capture anything from anywhere, but what if I just want to write a little paragraph or list? I am restricted by the handful of templates that are there (clipboard, contact, code snippet, etc...). And the templates are too bulky for me. I don't need all that big title, references, and large borders on the right side. I just want a blank area to type a little bit of text. So, that's one of the reasons why I wouldn't use the program at this point.
Anyway, I'm too tired to write anymore right now. But that is my complaint of Surfulater so far. It's just not a notetaking application yet, and I need that more so than it's spectacular ability to capture content. Let me put it this way, if you need to capture a lot of content without traditional notetaking (like you would in Keynote) than Surfulater is a great program for you, as in the case of jgiebeler, who sounds like he has to collect a whole lot of information from the web and other places. But if you're looking to organize a lot of simple text and little bits of information, you will be frustrated with Surfulater, it's just not meant for that yet.
So to bring this discussion all the way around to basic note-taking software, I will still assert that Mybase is closer to this goal than Surfulater. Capturing is only one part of notetaking, and it is an add-in (a luxury) at that. By that I mean that capturing is not the main goal of notetaking, so that shouldn't be the focus of this software genre. It could be the feature that makes one program better than the other, given that all else is equal, but it shouldn't be the primary focus. I think Surfulater's method of organizing it's articles with the multiple folders and (future) tags, is something that should be mirrored in a notetaking program also. That will bring this genre to the next level.