7551
Living Room / Re: Just like the MPAA didn't learn from the RIAA, the games industry is next
« Last post by wraith808 on February 08, 2012, 09:58 AM »If we take the basic empirical approach, then there is no debate whatsoever -- ideas cannot be property. Period. You can only have exclusive access to an idea if you never share/reveal it. But even then, someone else might think of the same idea... History is full of these kinds of things, e.g. Calculus with Liebniz and Descartes, even though it was known elsewhere centuries before.-Renegade (February 08, 2012, 12:06 AM)
While it is true that anything that you say or do that is not obfuscated in some manner cannot be owned, where does this leave the creative side of things? If you take the money grubbing out, and leave out the non-personal aspect of the corporations, and get back to the very basics as my example above... where is it right or fair that someone who creates this idea and does all of the work on it loses it just because they want to share what they did with the world?
If I create something with my writing that inspires others, then that's a great thing. But if someone takes my characters to make a profit off of those characters that I create, then in what place is that fair? And is the only choice give it away or keep it to yourself?

Recent Posts

)