7276
Living Room / Tags for multiple users - problems (& solutions?)
« Last post by tomos on December 23, 2010, 03:33 AM »I was querying what "Categories" to use for a new Q&A website and got this reply:
I dont use tagging much. I dont use any programme that really successfully implements tagging IMO.
One big problem is that, even if you have auto-complete and some sort of auto-list where new tags get added to the list, you're going to have people using different words for the same "thing".
Another approach - that could be combined with auto-complete/auto-list - would be that, when you click on a tag to see entries for it, it would be like a fuzzy search, showing e.g. pigs piggy and pig etc.
In order to get around the problem of different words being used for the same thing e.g. pig & swine - these could be manually associated so if you search for one, you get both.
Anyone know of any implementation of tagging for multiple users that helps minimise these problems? (software or website)
Re: categories, I'd be more in favor of tags. They're more flexible. Alternatively you could go with a system that allows suggesting new categories. With *either* solution you want an auto-complete of some kind or a "suggest" function so there is less chance for spelling-related miscategorization, etc.-JavaJones (December 22, 2010, 03:32 PM)
I dont use tagging much. I dont use any programme that really successfully implements tagging IMO.
One big problem is that, even if you have auto-complete and some sort of auto-list where new tags get added to the list, you're going to have people using different words for the same "thing".
Another approach - that could be combined with auto-complete/auto-list - would be that, when you click on a tag to see entries for it, it would be like a fuzzy search, showing e.g. pigs piggy and pig etc.
In order to get around the problem of different words being used for the same thing e.g. pig & swine - these could be manually associated so if you search for one, you get both.
Anyone know of any implementation of tagging for multiple users that helps minimise these problems? (software or website)

Recent Posts



There wont be any structural changes made to the site till Monday (Jan 3rd) or later
hang in there