...It's a powerful image, the tall grey man...
-tomos
Yes, perhaps it could be a powerful image - if you allowed it that - but it is still just a simple metaphor (a figure of speech in which a word or phrase is applied to something to which it is not literally applicable - a thing regarded as symbolic of something else), and thus it would seem irrational to enlarge the import of an imagined and intangible thing so far as to use it as a putative explanation for something somehow shaping mankind's perceptions throughout the course of our modern history.
-IainB
In this thread it was used as a symbol of what can/did happen to the individual during the growing-up process. In the 'did' case at least, it is not symbolic of anything 'imaginary' - but yes, I agree: it's not an
"explanation for something somehow shaping mankind's perceptions throughout the course of our modern history".
The writer of the article definitely has an "external locus of control", he doesnt seem to realise that
his problems (of being depressed/jaded with life) can only be solved within himself. Otherwise I think his article is a fairly brilliant rant against the dark sides of our society, and a good description/example of disillusionment with ideals. He comes across to me as completely genuine btw.
Re the history bit in your post Iain - and the in-depth sermon on religion:
- 1) if I know the history, should I then not be personally affected by war and everything it involves?
- 2) let's see, this will involve a few sub-items:
- a) off-topic in this depth for this thread
- b) off-topic for dc (religion and politics - even worse: the two combined)
- c) are you trying to persuade us, or yourself, about Israel's can-do-no-wrong reputation? (the author doesnt even seem to be picking on Israel, so I'm not really sure why you're posting all this stuff)
(For the record, I am no fan of Hamas.)
See now what I mean about your man's article being brilliant: he even has aspects of my post covered:
And, maybe most poisonous, maybe most soul-crushing: somebody said something I don’t like that makes me feel frightened and threatened! It’s time to put on my superhero costume and forward unto battle!
Except it doesn’t matter. Because you’re not really changing anybody’s mind. How often does that little skirmish end with anybody changing their mind at all, even a little bit?
- See more at: http://zenarchery.co...sthash.y4fzgYlF.dpuf
Recent Posts
from that: