8776
Living Room / Re: I'm ready to join the HTPC (home theater pc) revolution - what to get?
« Last post by mouser on September 20, 2013, 08:54 PM »A few more observations after a week of tweaking -- first some more XBMC complaints..
XBMC is an amazing open source project and it's amazing that it runs so well on so many different platforms.
It's also completely fails the test of being a set top replacement for a consumer device like a tivo etc -- for all but the most devoted users. It is simply packed to the brim with an insane navigational system and large gaping holes in functionality. It is absolutely and inexplicably painful to navigate around some of these side and context menus and perform certain operations, and it's absolutely braindead about lots of things. It may be ok for movie and tv browser but it's fairly terrible for online streaming and audio music.
If someone unfamiliar with XBMC came over to your house and you gave them the remote, the chance of them getting stuck in some sidebar context menu, triggering unwanted commands, and becoming frustrated is a near certainty.
Having said all that, i haven't seen anything better. But using something like this really makes you appreciate the work that goes into polishing a consumer GUI (like the TIVO) to make it intuitive and comfortable. XBMC gives you 10,000 alternate unsupported abaondoned broken "skins" and it's impossible to navigate. TIVO does not let you choose the skin but everything else works intuitively. What would you rather have?
Despite all my complaining, I still haven't found anything better for use as an htpc set top box (mainly for music) and XBMC does have a very high factor of cool if you want to hack around on it, which I have spent the last week doing. God knows how much will break over time -- it feels fragile. But there are some fun things to be done, and lots to explore and customize if you are into that kind of thing.
Jriver Media Center is still on my list of tools i'm playing with -- it has much nicer out-of-the-box music support, and much more power-user friendly interface in standard desktop application view. However, it falls down miserably on the htpc television screen (theatre) view, so that's what's stopping me there.
XBMC is an amazing open source project and it's amazing that it runs so well on so many different platforms.
It's also completely fails the test of being a set top replacement for a consumer device like a tivo etc -- for all but the most devoted users. It is simply packed to the brim with an insane navigational system and large gaping holes in functionality. It is absolutely and inexplicably painful to navigate around some of these side and context menus and perform certain operations, and it's absolutely braindead about lots of things. It may be ok for movie and tv browser but it's fairly terrible for online streaming and audio music.
If someone unfamiliar with XBMC came over to your house and you gave them the remote, the chance of them getting stuck in some sidebar context menu, triggering unwanted commands, and becoming frustrated is a near certainty.
Having said all that, i haven't seen anything better. But using something like this really makes you appreciate the work that goes into polishing a consumer GUI (like the TIVO) to make it intuitive and comfortable. XBMC gives you 10,000 alternate unsupported abaondoned broken "skins" and it's impossible to navigate. TIVO does not let you choose the skin but everything else works intuitively. What would you rather have?
Despite all my complaining, I still haven't found anything better for use as an htpc set top box (mainly for music) and XBMC does have a very high factor of cool if you want to hack around on it, which I have spent the last week doing. God knows how much will break over time -- it feels fragile. But there are some fun things to be done, and lots to explore and customize if you are into that kind of thing.
Jriver Media Center is still on my list of tools i'm playing with -- it has much nicer out-of-the-box music support, and much more power-user friendly interface in standard desktop application view. However, it falls down miserably on the htpc television screen (theatre) view, so that's what's stopping me there.

Recent Posts