But my biggest complaint is that it is too . . . pretty?
-James-B
Yeah, I actually had a similar problem with it. Somehow its skeuomorphism stands in the way of its functionality (despite the fact that it seems to be a very sophisticated software).
But the problem with these sorts of PIM and note-taking applications is that there is such a wide variety of user needs and software features and benefits that it takes a lot of careful analysis of one's needs and the software available to find the perfect match. E.g. there are ones that focus on capturing, or storing, or organising, or analysing notes, but few that can do all of those functions equally well.
E.g. if you want to store and organise notes, then there is the decision whether it should be a "tape", a hierarchical tree, a wiki, or some sort of a database interface. They all have their strengths and weaknesses.
And then there are the needs and computing skills of the user. Some software might turn out to be too basic, while others have too steep a learning curve.
There is a big difference between The Guide and OneNote, for instance. What functionality are you particularly looking for?