4151
Living Room / Re: Are Creative Commons Licenses Even Enforceable?
« Last post by TaoPhoenix on March 01, 2012, 03:04 PM »Interesting stuff.
From what I have seen, it's almost the other way around - everyone who "Shares" something that Infringes Copyright seems to be "Automatically ReLicensing" the original copyright into CC-BY-NC-SA. You know: "Hi Youtube, I posted this episode, it belongs to Warner Studios, no disrespect intended."-TaoPhoenix (March 01, 2012, 07:59 AM)
Technically, that's not true since the original copyright holder never gave them a license giving them permission to share it in the first place. Sharers that don't have a license to redistribute don't really have much of a leg to stand on in court if they get sued. And neither do those that reshare from them. A takedown notice sent to Youtube would get it removed and the uploader really wouldn't be able to dispute it by saying "but I have a license to redistribute it".-app103 (March 01, 2012, 02:32 PM)
I think we are agreeing, which suggests you haven't seen my "quotes" convention. A posted episode is certainly Infringing, no quotes. However when the poster uploads it and adds the key phrase "This is not mine, it's from the movie studio", I then meant that they are (yes, illegally) effectively altering the license. (Because you have to ask, either how can they not know that they are infringing, or they know they are but think that the penalties somehow don't apply to them.

Recent Posts



