9201
General Software Discussion / Re: an entire drive suddenly missing!
« on: May 06, 2010, 11:24 AM »--- you can set up a RAID 1 array for not much expense.-wraith808 (May 06, 2010, 10:14 AM)
-sounds interesting. However, I don't *need* a server (but may of course buy one all the same! haha), so if I am to think of it as solely a backup unit, I would say it is too fragile for the purpose. I might be paranoid, but I found this mini review of D-Link DNS-323:This drive is labeled as a backup drive or basically as a simple file server. All in all, it works well, until the unit fails. I used this as a file server running RAID 1 so that I had two copies of all of my files in case a drive failed. Only when the box failed and D-Link sent me a warranty replacement, did I learn there was no way to set up the new box without reformatting the drive and wiping out all of the data. After hours (and a lot of intense discussion with people on the other side of the Earth), we found a way to access the Linux file formatted drive on a Windows box and copy the files. If I had run this box in RAID 0 (which you would only do as a file server, not a backup drive), all of my data would have been lost. Be very careful when using this drive. Your data is not as safe as D-Link would like you to think.-Reviewer PC-PRO on Mar 11, 2010-Curt (May 06, 2010, 10:58 AM)
Hmmm... that shouldn't be the case, and in fact the Firmware supports adding a new drive (if not hot-swapping). Here's an in-depth review here:
http://www.smallnetb...t/view/30521/75/1/2/
It might be the firmware, but I couldn't say since he doesn't say what firmware he's using. The older firmware and builds were a problem (something in the kernel level drivers or some such), but this unit has been on the market for a while and I thought all the kinks were finally worked out...
Here's the relevant page from the DLink support:
http://www.support.d...1/103/help_tools.htm
I've been looking at getting one myself (my wife homeschools the kids and is going to a computer based system so she wants her data secure, and has just started college so we want her work secure), and this seemed like the best 'budget' NAS. As I side note, this is also the reason I'm looking at cloud services so intently.
And as another aside, his bit about his data being gone if he'd had it formatted as RAID 0- that's one of the downsides of RAID 0 no matter what. If one drive is gone, your data is going to be toast.