I have an idea that would work out well at the beginning, but not so well after a little while.
I was thinking that we could ship it out to people by post count order
. That is, people who have the most posts get Cody Plushie first. And to prevent people from artificially inflating their posts, we can just take a snapshot of where it is now.
The idea is to get Cody to the most active members on this forum first as a reward for being so awesome.
The problem is that there are some relatively new members who are active and contribute a lot but don't have a very high post count yet.