Main Area and Open Discussion > Living Room

troubling article: Adobe restricting pdf creation

(1/1)

mouser:
this is troubling..
one of the dangers of non-open file formats being adopted widely..

Microsoft told to remove PDF support from Office 2007

Microsoft raised a few eyebrows when it announced that it would natively support the ability to publish documents in Adobe PDF format. Given the popularity of PDF documents (for better or worse) on the web, support from Microsoft was seen by most as a nice addition for Office 2007.

That is all about to change now due to concerns raised by Adobe. The two companies were in talks for the past four months about the inclusion of PDF functionality in Office 2007, but those talks broke down recently. Microsoft contended that it is in the clear as far as native PDF support goes and that its customers have been asking for the features. Adobe countered by saying that Microsoft should either remove the feature altogether or charge customers for it. "The 'save as PDF' feature is the second most popular request we get from customers. Adobe has told the world that PDF is an open format...and (rival) products OpenOffice, WordPerfect Office and Apple (Computer's applications) already support PDF and tout it as a selling feature. Microsoft should be able to support PDF as well," stated Microsoft attorney Dave Heiner.

As a result of the legal bickering, Microsoft will remove not only the save as PDF feature that is available in Office 2007 Beta 2, but also the ability to save documents in Microsoft’s own XPS format. Customers will, however, be able to download both options as free downloads from Microsoft's Office homepage.

Brian Jones, program manager for Microsoft Office, is really disheartened over the whole situation. He recently wrote about his thoughts on the matter in his blog:

This really is one of those cases where you just have to shake your head. Adobe got a lot of goodwill with customers, particularly in government circles, for making PDF available as an open standard. It’s amazing that they would go back on the openness pledge. Unfortunately, the really big losers here are the customers who now have one extra hassle when they deploy Office.

--- End quote ---


http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=2662

JavaJones:
Bah, Adobe has been too big for their britches for a long time. This comes as no surprise to me. Did anyone ever *really* consider PDF an "open" standard anyway? It's one of those Microsoft-esque "Open as long as it benefits us" standards, right? :P

- Oshyan

Rover:
WARNING:  I'm going to use offensive language in this post.




You've been warned.



Piss on Adobe.... MS too for that matter.  Sun, IBM, HP, Dell, Oracle.  They're all bastards.  As soon as they think they have leverage on someone, they'll all pull a stunt link this.  "Everyone uses PDF, let's make 'em pay!"

This is one of the many reasons I support Donation Coder.  Let the egomanic CEO's piss enough customers off and we'll just have more happy donators.  I could rant for days...  :down: Adobe  :down: :down: :down:

Carol Haynes:
Also this article I posted yesterday ...

https://www.donationcoder.com/forum/index.php?topic=3883.msg27212#msg27212

mouser:
oh quite right; you did post about this didn't you? i'll merge mine into yours in a bit.

Navigation

[0] Message Index