DonationCoder.com Forum

Main Area and Open Discussion => General Software Discussion => Topic started by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 11:27 AM

Title: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 11:27 AM
I've got the green light to do a review of file renaming utilities, and I need your help in composing a list of the best file renamers out there. This review will acknowledge others, but will focus on the leading renamers within the category. Below is a [alphabetical] start, but what other [very good] renamers are there?

(01) 1-4A RENAME         F
         http://www.1-4a.com/rename/ (http://www.1-4a.com/rename/)

(02) ANT RENAMER      O
         http://www.antp.be/software/renamer (http://www.antp.be/software/renamer)

(03) BATCH RENAME      S
         http://batchrename.foryoursoft.com/ (http://batchrename.foryoursoft.com/)

(04) BETTER FILE RENAME      S
         http://www.publicspace.net/windows/BetterFileRename/ (http://www.publicspace.net/windows/BetterFileRename/)

(05) BULK RENAME UTILITY      D
         http://www.bulkrenameutility.co.uk/Main_Intro.php (http://www.bulkrenameutility.co.uk/Main_Intro.php)

(06) FILE RENAMER      S
         http://www.princetonsoftwarecompany.com/pr_renamer.htm (http://www.princetonsoftwarecompany.com/pr_renamer.htm)

(07) FILE RENAMER 2005      S
         http://www.filerenamer.net/index.htm (http://www.filerenamer.net/index.htm)

(08) FILE RENAMER BASIC      S
         http://www.sherrodcomputers.com/products_filerenamer.cfm (http://www.sherrodcomputers.com/products_filerenamer.cfm)

(09) FILE RENAMER PRO      S
         http://www.totaldownload.com/filerenamer/index.html (http://www.totaldownload.com/filerenamer/index.html)

(10) FLASH RENAMER      S
         http://www.rlvision.com/flashren/about.asp (http://www.rlvision.com/flashren/about.asp)

(11) FLEXIBLE RENAMER      F
         http://hp.vector.co.jp/authors/VA014830/english/FlexRena/ (http://hp.vector.co.jp/authors/VA014830/english/FlexRena/)

(12) LUPAS RENAME      D
         http://www.azheavymetal.com/~lupasrename/lupasrename.php (http://www.azheavymetal.com/~lupasrename/lupasrename.php)

(13) MAGIC FILE RENAMER      S
         http://www.finebytes.com/mfr/ (http://www.finebytes.com/mfr/)

(14) NYIoW, NAME IT YOUR WAY      S
         http://www.niyow.com/index.html (http://www.niyow.com/index.html)

(15) OSCAR'S FILE RENAMER      F
         http://www.mediachance.com/free/renamer.htm (http://www.mediachance.com/free/renamer.htm)

(16) PFRANK RENAMER         D
         http://www3.telus.net/pfrank/index.html (http://www3.telus.net/pfrank/index.html)

(17) PROFESSIONAL RENAMER      S
         http://www.miklsoft.com/profren/ (http://www.miklsoft.com/profren/)

(18) RENAMEFILES      F
         http://it-falke.com/software/renamefiles/us_description.php (http://it-falke.com/software/renamefiles/us_description.php)

(19) RENAME MASTER      D
         http://www.joejoesoft.com/rm.php (http://www.joejoesoft.com/rm.php)

(20) RENAMER         F
         http://www.redbrick.dcu.ie/~den4b/ (http://www.redbrick.dcu.ie/~den4b/)

(21) SOPHISTICATED RENAME    S
         http://acritum.com/sr/ (http://acritum.com/sr/)

(22) THE RENAME         D
         http://www.herve-thouzard.com/modules/wfsection/article.php?articleid=1 (http://www.herve-thouzard.com/modules/wfsection/article.php?articleid=1)

D = Donationware
F = Freeware
O = Open Source
S = Shareware

This is going to be a lot of fun, so if one of these is your favorite, please consider writing a mini-review of it and share with us what makes it stand out. I hope to have it completed by the end of May. Thanks!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: allen on March 31, 2006, 12:30 PM
I'm looking forward to seeing the results -- that said, I can't help much, you've already got my pick (Oscar's) in there.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 03:58 PM
Like you, Allen, I was surprised how easy Oscar's File Renamer was to use. I used Real-DRAW for several years and that cat was always coding. Moreover, I'm surprised it's freeware.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: kimmchii on March 31, 2006, 04:02 PM
the rename function in ExplorerXP (http://www.explorerxp.com/) is very user friendly.
freeware.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 04:07 PM
Wow, nice file manager kimmchii! I had no idea ExplorerXP was out there. This review will center around file renamers only, but for the person who wants to compose the "Review of File Managers," that is perhaps an essential feature. Thanks, now you've just cost me an hour of my life diving into ExplorerXP.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on March 31, 2006, 04:18 PM
Better File Rename
http://www.publicspace.net/windows/BetterFileRename/

(basically its a context menu extension, but quite good and very easy to use which makes it a good chioce much of the time)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 04:40 PM
Got it! Would seem handy for quickly renaming a series within a folder.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: patteo on March 31, 2006, 10:36 PM
I was looking for a file renamer about two years ago and one of those which I settled on was D-FileMU.

One of the key features that drew me to it (if my memory does not fail me) were the extensive command line arguments available. And this is very handy when you want to automate the process of file renaming.

Perhaps in the review, some coverage of the quality of command line arguments could be covered for automation freaks.

I did look at some of those in the list you started off with and do not remember coming across one with as extensive command line arguments as D-FileMU.

And don't be fooled by the plain looking website. It host a pretty capable file renamer than it appears. And it's Freeware.

Extract from very plain looking home page.
"D-FileMU
D-FilenameManipulationUtility is a utility that allows you to make changes to filenames of a number of files quickly and easily. It can perform changes such as adding strings to the beginning and end of the filenames, deleting specified number of characters from beginning or end of the filenames, adding numbers in sequence to the beginning or end of the filenames, changing to upper or lowercase, Adding or removing the read only(+r) or hidden(+h) or archive(+a) file attributes, replacing strings with specified string, changing the file extension of filenames and also capitalizing words. The program can also be used as a command line utility.

The program is easy to use, very quick in performing the changes and also allows the user to preview the changes before performing them."
http://www.dimbu.com/programs4free/d-filemu/

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on March 31, 2006, 11:04 PM
Thanks patteo for the suggestion on command line utility features and for synopsizing the program for us. Most renamers don't go that far. D-FileMU — I wonder how that name came about?
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: patteo on April 01, 2006, 01:09 AM
Another one is Siren but I have not tested it. I only checked to see if there were command line arguments available since I was looking from the automation perspective.

http://www.scarabee-software.net/en/index.html

It's Freeware

Personally I think Command line commands is a must if you really want to automate anything with utilities like that . Yes, it would be nice to have a nice GUI. But I think, no one should take away the command line functions in the process and it is sad that in the process of making utilities for the masses, many developers forget that there's a group who can really benefit from such commands. So effectively, they end up crippling the software for them.




Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on April 01, 2006, 01:24 AM
patteo makes an interesting point - the review should mention the extent of commandline support of each renamer.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 02, 2006, 01:23 AM
Duly noted. I also found another one through a reader (Kiwi2b) on my blog (http://www.thegsblog.com/), simply titled, File Renamer (http://www.princetonsoftwarecompany.com/pr_renamer.htm).
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: herbiman on April 02, 2006, 08:11 AM
You seem to have missed my favorite -- Magic File Renamer

http://www.finebytes.com/mfr/
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: brotherS on April 02, 2006, 08:27 AM
BatchRename: http://fileforum.betanews.com/detail/BatchRename/1061233630/1
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: AbteriX on April 02, 2006, 08:36 AM
ANT Renamer - F - http://www.antp.be/software/ - http://www.buypin.com
eRename - F - http://hansjoerg.reister.bei.t-online.de/erename/
ReNamer - F - [den4b] - Denis Kozlov - http://www.redbrick.dcu.ie/~den4b/
Renamer 6.0 Final - F - Albert Bertilsson - www.albert.nu
Sophisticated Rename 1.7
(Last Freeware Version)
- F - http://www.aplusfreeware.com/categories/util/renaming.html
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 02, 2006, 05:55 PM
AbteriX, out of curiosity, which one do you like best, or do you use most often? (I couldn't bring up the eRename site.)

Also, thanks herbiman and brotherS for the recs! I get excited hoping to find a better app than what I'm using.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: AbteriX on April 03, 2006, 02:17 AM
I am  playing around with BulkRenameUtility 'cus it's on development. Mostly i play with RegEx and help others in the forum.

I am playing also with THE Renamer and translate it to german. He have a lot of power if you take the time to take a closer look.
e.g. rerange files by there first chars in corresponding folders.

I think most i like FlexRen, wich i also have translated to german, 'cus of hes regex possibilities.

But most i use the renamer plugin of Servant Salamander.


... have to go... perhaps later more if you have questions.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: AbteriX on April 03, 2006, 02:25 AM
the eRename "side" is here
https://www.donationcoder.com/forum/index.php?topic=1902.msg12804#msg12804
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: brotherS on April 03, 2006, 02:40 AM
I get excited hoping to find a better app than what I'm using.
I believe many are by now :)

Btw, I'd love if you'd include the BetaNews/FileForum ratings like LuckMan212 did on https://www.donationcoder.com/forum/index.php?topic=2566.new;topicseen#new
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 03, 2006, 05:56 AM
Personally I think Command line commands is a must if you really want to automate anything with utilities like that

Don't overlook Horst Schaeffer's (http://home.mnet-online.de/horst.muc/) LMOD (click DOS/BATCH, then LMOD)

Quote from Horst's Web site:

LMOD extracts data from an input source (STDIN): from redirected DOS screen output, for example, or from any (ASCII) file. The extracted information is inserted into a given text or command string, and sent to STDOUT for redirection into a file.

You may extract a complete line, a part of it (starting column, size) or words (by number), even several items from a source line in any order. And this will be done either for a single line, or for a given range of lines of the input source.

What you can do with LMOD:

    * set environmental variables with information from (DOS) screen output
    * get keyboard input
    * generate a command using extracted input data
    * generate a list of commands for each item of a given (file) list
    * extract (and modify) range of lines from a file
    * modify lists or tables, arrange columns

To set a variable: generate a SET command (or WINSET / SETX), and execute it thru a temporary batch file. This method also works under Windows NT/2000.

Special Features:

    * change case for extracted data
    * tabs (to given column) for formatted output
    * right aligned fields (numeric data in tables)
    * insert CR+LF to generate several lines for each input line
    * omit CR+LF at end of output (to append later)
    * insert line number (to generate filenames, for example)
    * insert special characters by code number or in quoted string

Redirect a DIR listing and use LMOD for file renaming.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 03, 2006, 10:48 AM
Command-line tool, Renamer, formerly BKRenamer: http://www.orbit.org/renamer/

Favourably mentioned in Mark TAW's smallwares (http://www.orbit.org/renamer/), viz.:
a great regular expression, command-line no-install tool. BKRenamer is great when you have to do a change all the file names in several directories because it can search through subdirectories as well.

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: tsaint on April 03, 2006, 05:43 PM
Another is PFrank -
brief review at http://www.snapfiles.com/reviews/PFrank/pfrank.html (http://www.snapfiles.com/reviews/PFrank/pfrank.html)
Author's site at http://www3.telus.net/pfrank/ (http://www3.telus.net/pfrank/)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 03, 2006, 11:48 PM
Thanks guys, I really appreciate these suggestions. I can't wait to dig into these. When you take 20-30 programs and start using them next to one another, you'd be surprised how quickly the cream rises to the top. More than a few developers have written renamers for their own needs rather than for mass consumption, you several of you point out.

However, I will point out that I know very little about regular expressions and command-line utilities. While these will be noted, those naturally fall into a sub-category that might merit a second, more detailed review of these only. This review will focus mainly on the best GUI file renamer not excluding command-line, text, and RegEx abilities. If the scope is not somehow limited, then the review begins to make unfair or misaligned comparisons. Right now, I want to look at everything that's good, not just every renamer available. Fortunately, you all can help me with that last part!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on April 04, 2006, 12:12 AM
regular expression search and replace is quite important -
allen here is an expert on them, and so are some others.  would be nice to have them make some early comments on how well the top contenders do on regex before you make up your mind about top candidates.

id say with such a big field, any renamer without good regex support should probably not get the top nod.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 04, 2006, 01:34 AM
Excellent! I've asked patteo to consider filtering out the best renamers with regard to command-line utility, and maybe allen, et al. can help sort the best of the RegEx renamers. I know some renamers "claim" RegEx abilities, but I've no idea if they deliver on them, nor would I know if they did.

I won't pretend to know more than I do, but in the search for the best, we should make sure we don't miss a powerhouse! :-)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 04, 2006, 03:32 AM
Please let's not overlook drawbacks and problems.

The company I work for have gimmicked the networked computers so that many applications are unable to see the C: drive (IT Dept. trying to force you to use networked drives only).  This is true of both Bulk Rename Utility (BRU) and Oscar's, for example.  I e-mailed Jim Willsher, BRU's author, and he replied:

Yes, they will have implemented Group Policy to restrict access to the drive. My utility reads the Shell Namespace, which will honour the restrictions. Your other utilities will operate on the drive directly.

My "other" relevant utilities that do work are the multi-rename tool built into Total Commander (thank goodness), 1-4a and Lupas Rename.

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 04, 2006, 03:40 AM
Here's another interesting sideline from TinyApps blog (http://www.tinyapps.org/weblog/)

Question about drag & drop with auto incrementing of filenames #
Is there a method for dragging and dropping a list of files with the same name into a new folder and have them automatically increment the filenames rather than give an overwrite warning? Two instances where I've seen this work: when dragging files from a search result window into Nero (screenshot) and when dragging email messages from Outlook Express into Explorer. I'm not looking for a renamer to change the original filenames, but rather a way to create new files with incremented names. Answers sent to "mail AT tinyapps DOT org" will be appended to this post.

UPDATE: Jorg Kliemann has kindly crafted a solution.

Continuing, here's the solution:

DROP++ #
Jorg Kliemann has generously crafted DROP++ (http://member.eduhi.at/j.kliemann/wiki/wiki.php?page=Downloads) (source available here (http://member.eduhi.at/j.kliemann/wiki/wiki.php?page=sourcecode-droppp)) using AutoIt (itself a mostly open source project) to address the drag & drop overwrite problem mentioned recently. Simply drag and drop a group of files from search results or any other Explorer window onto its icon; DROP++ will copy the files and autoincrement the resulting filenames. If you're tired of seeing "Confirm File Replace - This folder already contains a file named foo. Would you like to replace the existing file with this one?", give DROP++ a try. (By the way, holding Shift while clicking No to the above dialog behaves like "No to All", which is otherwise not provided.)



Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 04, 2006, 05:05 AM
RJ, I'm at a disadvantage, since I'm neither on a networked computer nor can I imagine why a rename utility would need to override permissions on a network. Virtually every corporation/company I've ever worked for severely restricts what users can see and do these days. Also, I don't understand what the TinyApps blog entry quote is trying to say with regard to file rename utilities. Help me out. Finally, any idea if there are other utilities exist other than 1-4a and Lupas Rename that can do what you say?

Let us know, thanks!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 04, 2006, 09:08 AM
Virtually every corporation/company I've ever worked for severely restricts what users can see and do

Security is a common justification for paranoia, but in this case I don't think its strictly speaking a security (as in hack attack) issue.  The IT Dept. try to force us to use networked directories beause they claim to back those up, whereas they can't back up the directories on your local hard disk.  But they don't understand what real users need to do.

I don't understand what the TinyApps blog entry quote is trying to say with regard to file rename utilities.

I think he's trying to say, suppose you have a directory with a file called foo.bar in it, and you're about to copy it to another directory.  But, that directory already contains a different file with the same name, and you want to keep both of them intact.  The idea is to avoid conflicts or overwrites by renaming files on the fly, adding suffix numbers to the file names if source and target names are the same.  Rather a specialised trick.

any idea if there are other utilities exist other than 1-4a and Lupas Rename that can do what you say?

I haven't looked at many other renamers.  RenameFiles 2.42 at http://renamefiles.it-falke.com  can see my C: drive, though it's more basic than some mentioned so far (but available in German as well as English, for our small but honourable German contingent).  Many other sorts of programs work fine, such as the excellent DoubleKiller.  In both these cases you can just type in the path you want, and the program will go there.  This doesn't work with BRU, where nothing happens.


Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 04, 2006, 06:57 PM
Thanks RJ, that's clearer to me now. It's a shame that any company/IT fool would restrict all access to your C-drive. Hey, and some of my favorite software (and operas) originate from Deutschland! One thing that is that Bulk Rename Utility admits is its limitations when reading its forum or Help File. For example, BRU cannot rename files using mp3 track information. Its developer, Jim Willsher, holds that mp3 extraction slows down the program too much and recommends specific mp3 renamers for that purpose.

For many, that's a significant negative; for others, it's good because the program doesn't sacrifice speed. It's funny you mention Jan Falke's RenameFiles (http://it-falke.com/software/renamefiles/us_description.php) utility. When you open it up, it does 90% of what most people do with a renamer on the fly. I love his description of Preview: (for cowards!)

        (http://it-falke.com/software/renamefiles/us_screenshot_maindialog.png)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: noth(a)nk.you on April 04, 2006, 07:24 PM
AbteriX mentioned the utility I use,

Renamer 6.0 Final - F - Albert Bertilsson - www.albert.nu

It's very much freeware, light, and fast.  Plus, after using it for a few years, I've never wanted it to do something more than it already does.

I highly recommend it.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on April 04, 2006, 08:08 PM
I love his description of Preview: (for cowards!)

 ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers
Post by: Cavalcader on April 04, 2006, 11:33 PM
Maybe this upcoming renamers review could somehow be the first part of a "mass file maintenance" overview. For example, I use a cool (free) tool called "Directify!" (http://www.n37dev.com/Products/Directify/) that auto-creates subdirs based on existing filename patterns and then moves the files to them. Truly indispensable if you've ever needed something like that.  :-*

Here're the current command options if you're interested...
Spoiler
---------------------------------------------------------
Directify! v.0.0.2 (beta) for NTFS partitions
Copyright (c) 2004-2005 N37dev - All Rights Reserved
www.n37dev.com for updates/bug reports
---------------------------------------------------------

Usage: [-<switch options>] [directory]

The following switch options can be combined:

-V Verbose output


Filters

-D/string/      Only consider characters left of delimiter string
-E/chars/       Exclude files starting with specified characters
-I/chars/       Include files starting with specified characters
-M/filemask/    Consider only files dictated by mask
-S              Case sensitive comparisons
-T/threshold/   Number of matches required before creating directory


Preprocessing

-C              Convert underscores and dots to spaces
-W              Remove last word from proposed directory name
-R/string/      Remove string from filename


Grouping Modes

-A              Grouping Mode 1
-B              Grouping Mode 2 (more strict)
-s/string/      Group only files containing string

-L Live Mode    ***CHANGES WILL BE MADE***

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on April 05, 2006, 03:05 AM
great find Cavalcader!
i'd love to see a list of similar programs - i've been looking for such a tool myself.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: GHammer on April 05, 2006, 04:12 AM
I use the rename mod in Directory Opus 8, but before that, I used Name It Your Way (http://www.niyow.com/) which was very nice in my usage.

ReNamer (http://www.redbrick.dcu.ie/~den4b/) is a nice free tool as well, just updated in fact.

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: womtag on April 08, 2006, 10:25 PM
I see that Ant Renamer (http://www.antp.be/software/renamer) was briefly mentioned earlier. I have been really impressed by this one and have been using it for quite some time. Admittedly I haven't tried many others, but I think that is because I've been very happy with Ant. So hopefully it can make it to the list in the top post, and perhaps into the review itself.

You're asking for a mini-review, Zaine, I'll do my best and will try to do a write up of what I like about this one at least.

First of all, unlike some other renamers it hasn't got a big, cluttered interface where everything is forced upon the user at once, in a big window with lots of information. Ant uses a different approach with two different main views, Files view and Actions view, that you toggle between. I find the application interface very thoughtfully laid out, with a focus on user friendliness that should work well for both beginners and advanced users.

You start by adding files through drag & drop or by using standard Windows "open" menus. Sort files using the columns or by dragging files to the desired position if the order is important, ie for number renaming.

Then change to Actions view where you select the desired action to take. By default you choose only one action from a list. I think this is a good way to approach file renaming, because most users will only have one thing they want to change about a set of files at a given time. While configuring your action you will see a live preview of the what this action will do to the file that is currently selected in the Files view. Also displayed are notes and tips about what the current action can do. Text boxes have a drop down feature where you can select previously entered strings. Neat.

Of course you can also do complex renaming with several actions at once by clicking to activate the batch feature. If you have a procedure that you want to repeat regularly you can save the batch actions to a file (xml-style) and load it later on a different file set. Personally, I like this approach to do complex file renaming by sort of reducing all the changes you want to make into a comprehensible list of separate changes. Saved batch files can be used with the program as a command line tool by loading files and performing the actions in the batch file on them - I haven't tried this myself though.

There is also a third view, the Log view, where it's possible to see all the renaming operations that was performed. Here you can filter to show only errors or successes in the renaming operation.

One thing that deserves mention is the use of keyboard shortcuts throughout the program, for me that is welcome in any program. Tip: Hit F5 when in Actions view to see an update of the renaming previews in Files view.

Ant Renamer is one of the programs where the author has taken the time to provide a well-written help file. Even if I could figure out most of the program without it as a new user without file renaming experiences, I still found it a pleasure to see such a good overview of the functions in the help file.

There is now a new beta version (http://forum.antp.be/phpbb2/viewtopic.php?t=2528) out with RegExp support. I've read about RegExp before, looks interesting, slightly difficult but very powerful. Guess I'll have to check it out eventually.

The program is freeware (GPL), sure doesn't hurt either.

I hope you will find time to check it out as a candidate to the review, Zaine. You obviously have a lot more experience than me with file renamers, so I'm a little curious as to how you feel my favorite stacks up with the best of them. Unfortunately I don't see Ant Renamer mentioned very often when people recommend file renamers, but I suspect this is not related to the quality of the software, but rather to low publicity.

By the way, big thanks to allen for letting me know about Oscar's Renamer, great tool. A mighty fine complement to Ant Renamer for my uses.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 08, 2006, 11:50 PM
Wow, thanks womtag, that helps out a lot, and I'm happy to add it. I hope you added this to the Mini-Review section, too!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 08, 2006, 11:54 PM
Just noticed, we're up to 18 solid programs, great!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 09, 2006, 02:27 PM
For example, BRU cannot rename files using mp3 track information. Its developer, Jim Willsher, holds that mp3 extraction slows down the program too much and recommends specific mp3 renamers for that purpose.

That's not a bug, that's a feature  :)

Jan Falke's RenameFiles (http://it-falke.com/software/renamefiles/us_description.php) utility. When you open it up, it does 90% of what most people do with a renamer on the fly. I love his description of Preview: (for cowards!)

A place I go on holiday has several coats of arms in its stained-glass windows.  The motto of one of them reads "Non timeo sed caveo," which my rusty Latin translates as "I am not afraid, but I am cautious"  :D

I think you're right that Jan Falke's program does most of what most people want, but it isn't as visual as some of the others.  I mostly now use the multi-rename tool built into Total Commander, which remembers the "macros" for inserting text at specific points, remembers search-and-replace strings, etc., in pull-downs  This seems similar to what's been said above about Ant Renamer, which I haven't tried.

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 09, 2006, 10:42 PM
RJ, your comment is quite common in my email this week. Seems most people use other tools, viz., their file managers like Total Commander or Directory Opus to rename files on the fly. This fact of utilization will need to be noted within the review, I believe.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: rjbull on April 10, 2006, 04:29 AM
RJ, your comment is quite common in my email this week. Seems most people use other tools, viz., their file managers like Total Commander or Directory Opus to rename files on the fly. This fact of utilization will need to be noted within the review, I believe.

The Epilog to The AWK Programming Language by Aho, Kernighan and Weinberger says they were astonished at seeing people writing AWK scripts that were more than one page long, as they had conceived of AWK as one-liners or very short scripts.  It seemed that
rather than writing in a "real" programming language, [people] were stretching the tools they liked.

Perhaps the built-in, ready-to-hand, familiar tools are adequate for most people, most of the time?

Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 10, 2006, 04:42 PM
I think so. For example, I download massive photo sets from models' galleries, which are updated once or twice a week. Problem is, you either have to rename the files or put them all in separate folders most of the time. I'd rather just rename them with the padded number, such as "file_0001.jpg, file_0002.jpg, file_0003.jpg," etc. The other renaming I do most of the time is cleaning up file names. So it makes sense that if a renamer is integrated into another program, such as your file manager, that you would look to use that because it's so close at hand.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 11, 2006, 04:26 PM
JUST AN UPDATE. It looks like we have most all of the renamers listed for this review, and I can begin working with them one by one. If anyone else knows of a good or great renamer application, share it with us here. As always, thanks for your help with this.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 13, 2006, 03:48 AM
Added NIYoW (http://www.niyow.com/index.html), Name It Your Way as perhaps the last app considered for the review. That gives us an even 20 apps and we'll see if we can make it interesting.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: brotherS on April 13, 2006, 08:31 AM
Perhaps the built-in, ready-to-hand, familiar tools are adequate for most people, most of the time?
Most of the familiar tools are adequate for most people all the time - because they just don't care to search for a better solution.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: brotherS on April 13, 2006, 08:34 AM
Added NIYoW (http://www.niyow.com/index.html), Name It Your Way as perhaps the last app considered for the review. That gives us an even 20 apps and we'll see if we can make it interesting.
I'm really looking forward to the review! While I don't rename files every day such a tool can save huge amounts of time and reduce your stress-level at the same moment.

:)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: superboyac on April 13, 2006, 10:43 AM
RJ, your comment is quite common in my email this week. Seems most people use other tools, viz., their file managers like Total Commander or Directory Opus to rename files on the fly. This fact of utilization will need to be noted within the review, I believe.

True.  I use Directory Opus for my renaming needs, and befor that, I used Total Commander.  I'm sure, that the standalone apps are more powerful, but since I've used it, I've never had to go beyond the ability of Dopus or TC. 
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 13, 2006, 04:40 PM
Once again, superboyac makes a good point that must be acknowledged: What tool do people use to rename files? I'll include a brief section on this, and superboyac, et al. if you will send me a note on what you like, and what is good about the renaming component of Total Commander, Directory Opus, and so on, I'd be grateful for the info.

Although its another review of utility software (for me), like brotherS made me think about, I think a file renamer gives you direct control over your files and folders. If you know where to find it or its name, then you can use either your desktop search client or a utility like FileLocator Pro (http://www.mythicsoft.com/default.aspx) to get there fast.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: superboyac on April 13, 2006, 06:27 PM
Yeah, sometimes I find myself to be a little hypocritical.  If you read my posts, you'll often see me violently opposed to all-in-one applications, and I always generalize that single-task power applications are always better than one application that tries to do everything.  That's just the nature of things.  You can't do everything well, but it's easy to do one thing really well.

So, I guess I sound like a hypocrite when I say I use my file manager as my file renamer.  But, upon closer inspection, it's not as hypocritical as it seems.  I still believe that a standalone file renamer is probably much better than what is available in DOpus or TC.  But the reason I use DOpus is because it does what I need it to do perfectly well, so I have no desire to explore or even use a separate application for it.

To answer your request, zridling, I'll describe how the renaming works in DOpus.  Once you open the window, you have all sorts of options of how to rename the file using regxp, or just search and replace, or series numbering, etc.  Basic stuff.  There's a preview pane to see the results before you commit.  It's pretty powerful, I would say I've only used about 10% of what is capable of doing.  I can't even relate to people who need something more powerful, but I acknowledge that my needs are much simpler than some other people.

The renamer for Total Commander is pretty much the same as DOpus, it seems like they are equally powerful.  I'll say this much, I thought the interface for TC was slightly easier to use and understand that DOpus.  That's about all I can say about file renaming from my experience.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on April 13, 2006, 10:05 PM
...the reason I use DOpus is because it does what I need it to do perfectly well,....

Exactly, and if it fills your needs, then it is perfect for you. Many people search for alternatives to programs like Microsoft Word because they don't need to write dissertations; just memos, letters, and short documents. Thanks for the description, that's a great help. I just noticed that the Rename feature in Directory Opus is so powerful because it not only uses Regular Expressions, but autofills them for you! Freakin' awesome! It even allows you to input and save any other form of renaming you want if you want.

          (http://www.anova.org/target/dcc/dopus-rename01.png)

          (http://www.anova.org/target/dcc/dopus-rename02.png)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: brotherS on April 13, 2006, 10:44 PM
[...] like brotherS made me think about, I think a file renamer gives you direct control over your files and folders. If you know where to find it or its name, then you can use either your desktop search client or a utility like FileLocator Pro (http://www.mythicsoft.com/default.aspx) to get there fast.
Don't forget to mention the great and free Locate here :) https://www.donationcoder.com/forum/index.php?topic=1385.0 has all the info, it's blazing fast and brought the fun back to searches!
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: vegas on May 15, 2006, 10:12 AM
One of the better ones has been updated 2006-05-14,  Flash Renamer http://www.rlvision.com/flashren/whatsnew.asp
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on May 15, 2006, 05:52 PM
I noticed that, too. Flash Renamer (http://www.rlvision.com/flashren/about.asp) is a solid renamer. Just to do basic renaming, though, start at the 'numbers' tab. I like how it returns to the same place every time, and yes, has a keyboard shortcut for the rename operation.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: vegas on May 28, 2006, 03:56 PM
I don't know how far along you are with your review, but I also noticed some good renaming capabilities of the free G6 Utilities from Gene6 http://www.gene6.com/ (mid-way down the page).
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: zridling on May 28, 2006, 10:55 PM
Thanks for the suggestion Vegas. However, between being sick on and off for the past six weeks, travel time between Chicago and Missouri, and now that summer is here, I will be too busy to complete this review. I had worked through a few when I felt well, and after listing 15 — 15! — criteria that goes into making a good renamer, decided the job was too overwhelming. Thus I won't be doing this review after all.

Most renamers do not share a commonly recognizable (or transferable) interface, and it was taking longer than I expected to learn those I was unfamiliar with. So I admit defeat! I apologize for letting you guys down. If I did continue it, I'd need another six months just to find the time now.

- Zaine Ridling

________________________________________________
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: mouser on May 28, 2006, 11:27 PM
i know i speak for everyone when i say we'd rather have a healthy zaine and no review than a review and an institutionalized zaine...

anyone want to pick up the torch and continue this review?
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: ur1sn00per on October 23, 2006, 05:47 AM
p3do Explorer [www.senosoft.com] uses Pattern Renamer plugin to rename *thumbnails*. If you are renaming images this is very convenient and covers most requirements very simply. Discovering this was a mammoth event.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: superboyac on October 23, 2006, 09:23 AM
I feel your pain, Z.  These reviews are hard work.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: Renegade on October 23, 2006, 10:19 AM
I've used Flash Renamer before, and found it quite good.

But holy mother! There are just soooo many. It would be easier for me to create my own than to review them and choose a decent one.

So - for lazy/busy ol' me - what's the final verdict? Directory Opus looks a bit ugly... Is the power worth it?
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: superboyac on October 23, 2006, 01:07 PM
I've used Flash Renamer before, and found it quite good.

But holy mother! There are just soooo many. It would be easier for me to create my own than to review them and choose a decent one.

So - for lazy/busy ol' me - what's the final verdict? Directory Opus looks a bit ugly... Is the power worth it?
I love Directory Opus, but I have to say that I can't figure out the renamer tool, it's just too wild and complicated.  All those (./*) symbols I couldn't figure out, nor could I find much help in the help file about it.  I can do simple things, but as soon as I start tweaking and needing to use those symbols, I'm lost.  It's one of those things where the programmers have felt that to maximize the power of the renamer, they have to make it as raw as possible.  Actually, if there is a concise tutorial about the DOpus method, I'd be very interested.  But emphasis on concise.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: f0dder on March 09, 2007, 08:43 AM
*bump*.

Anybody's going to finish the review? :)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: iphigenie on March 09, 2007, 09:13 AM
I tried at least 15 of the ones mentioned and the oneI use and often pass around is FlexRenamer (11) / the live preview means I could give it to designers to do their own image file name cleanups
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: f0dder on March 09, 2007, 09:42 AM
Preview is definitely a must in such an app, and so is regular expressions. I checked out 1-4a renamer which did the job for the simple rename I needed, but wouldn't recommend that app - super messy interface.

The screenshots for FlexRename look a bit messy because of all the japanese + bugs :)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: MerleOne on March 09, 2007, 10:49 AM
I use a lot the file multiple-renaming capability of Total Commander, which is very powerful (wildcards, regex - I think, and so on).  Not easy to use at first, but when one get a hand on this, it's so convenient.

To activate it : select files then press Ctrl-M
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: iphigenie on March 10, 2007, 06:35 AM
They all seem to have slightly quirky interface  :-\

If you want non japanese screenies of FlexRename I can make some.
That program has far more features than I have ever used

* regexp and wildcard and char-2-char replace
* lots of "pre-canned" renames which are configurable and help you without having to do a regex (dates, cleanup operations like removing "copy n of" or "shortcut to"
* renames based on meta information, iptc, exif, music tags (not ogg yet), office meta tags (MS, not the open office format), html meta tags
* save your options as preset, retrieve them
* all the usual options move-and-rename, copy-and-rename but also delete-what-matches (technically not a rename). change or don't change the date etc.
* files selected by folder, or drag-and-drop to build the list
* add to context menu to run the program or a search from normal explorer use

But mostly I like it because  the listing of the files even with subfolders is very fast and so is the preview of whatever transformation you are asking. It feels instantaneous to me. That's the killer feature.

I'm sure many of the other tools in the list have similar features, but once I found this one I kept coming back to it. It's free too.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: PlayPhil on March 10, 2007, 09:38 AM
Greetings, just joined. By far the best renamer I've ever used is Lupas Rename... :up:

http://rename.lupasfreeware.org/

Why he gives it away for zip is beyond me.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: Darwin on March 10, 2007, 09:46 AM
I've been using Bulk Rename Utility (http://www.bulkrenameutility.co.uk/Features.php) for years and it does everything that I need. I'm a big fan. I was using The Rename  (http://www.herve-thouzard.com/modules/wfsection/article.php?articleid=1#t2) before that and liked it enough to make a donation, but BRU blows it away (yes, have donated to BRU too!).
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: PlayPhil on March 10, 2007, 09:52 AM
Hmmm, very interesting, esp the command line version...  :)
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: PhilB66 on March 22, 2008, 12:43 AM
Adding Métamorphose (http://file-folder-ren.sourceforge.net/) (free and open source) to the long list of file and folder renaming tools and utilities.
Title: Re: Review of File Renamers — let's make a list
Post by: Curt on June 18, 2008, 08:25 AM
Métamorphose (http://file-folder-ren.sourceforge.net/)-1 was just updated (http://sourceforge.net/project/showfiles.php?group_id=146403) to version 1.1.1, and Métamorphose-2 to version 0.4.3 Beta.

Also, I like to use both the free ReNamer by den4b (http://www.den4b.com/) and the pretty $20 File Renamer Deluxe (http://www.kristanixsoftware.com/filerenamer/) by Kristianix.