Main Area and Open Discussion > Living Room
Microsoft patches applied - EVEN WHEN AUTOUPDATE IS OFF
Josh:
Too bad for me? I love *nix, but I also dont dilute myself into believing it could ever take the place of windows for 90% of users. There is a reason it hasnt taken off yet, lets just leave it at that and let this thread go back to its topic.
Ralf Maximus:
Actually, it *is* a big deal. Reaching into my computer and changing files -- any files -- when I have expressly denied permission is wrong. Even with the best of intentions, mistakes happen. Recall the WGA disaster of a month ago where Vista machines went dark because they couldn't phone home? All Microsoft's fault, no malicious intent, but the incident should be a wake up call.
How would you feel if one morning you discovered your Windows validation had been revoked, only due to a mistake? They have demonstrated they can stealth-modify files. Even more troubling, the article states there is no way to learn what was modified or why -- only the date & filename are available. No KB article. This is not transparent behavior, and one is compelled to wonder why? If it's a simple bug fix, then say so. The fact they go to some lengths to obsfucate the matter is more upsetting than the action itself.
I utilize a fully-paid MSDN platform subscription for all my Windows test machines. It's not difficult to imagine a block of serial numbers accidently deactivated, and the news sent down the wire to my little herd of test mules. Suddenly I cannot conduct business. What recourse then?
Or try out this far fetched, but still plausible scenario: MS licensing policy changes, and XP schedules itself to stop working on a particluar date, forcing a migration to Vista?
Until we learn more, there is nothing good to say about these activities or by extension the policies they enact.
Carol Haynes:
And another article (with a vote at the bottom) ...
http://blogs.zdnet.com/hardware/?p=779#more-779
I have added a poll at the top of this thread ...
katykaty:
Can you add another option:
They shouldn't really do it, but life's too short to care
;)
Carol Haynes:
True - but I think you are stuck with Don't Care or Buy me a beer
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version