Main Area and Open Discussion > Living Room

Elastic Lists - The Possible Future of Semantic Search

(1/1)

Paul Keith:
Source: http://moritz.stefaner.eu/projects/elastic-lists/

Elastic lists allow to navigate large, multi-dimensional info spaces with just a few clicks, never letting you run into situations with zero results. They enhance traditional UI approaches for facet browsers by visualizing weight proportions, animated transitions, emphasis of characteristic values and sparkline visualizations
--- End quote ---

NY Times Article search demo: (Warning requires Javascript)

http://moritz.stefaner.eu/projects/elastic-lists/NYT/

Forgot where I got the link:

http://thenoisychannel.com/2010/05/20/elastic-lists-for-faceted-search-now-open-source/



To me, it shows everything that can go wrong with faceted search. Try a search for [google] in that demo. If you have the reaction I did, you’ll hit immediate paradox of choice from all the options presented, many of which seem almost random.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m a huge fan of faceted search when implemented well. I’m just not sure this is the best example of a well done implementation?

That demo has issues, but I don’t think those damn elastic lists per se. Some of my criticisms: too many facet values as refinement options, lack of parallelism (e.g., locations aren’t hierarchical and some options should be children of others), lack of normalization of organizations (e.g., google and google inc.), and a confusing description facet (e.g., choices include “computer software” and “software”). In contrast, the Nobel Prize demo strikes me as a much better demo of elastic lists.
--- End quote ---

Renegade:
Very interesting!

That demo has issues, but I don’t think those damn elastic lists per se. Some of my criticisms: too many facet values as refinement options, lack of parallelism (e.g., locations aren’t hierarchical and some options should be children of others), lack of normalization of organizations (e.g., google and google inc.), and a confusing description facet (e.g., choices include “computer software” and “software”). In contrast, the Nobel Prize demo strikes me as a much better demo of elastic lists.
--- End quote ---
-Paul Keith (June 17, 2010, 05:50 PM)
--- End quote ---

Good observation there.

The thing there is the size... You need a very high degree of normalization in order to get that interface correct. The top navigation represents how the data is normalized to drill down into.

The overall concept is nothing new --- filtered results. The implementation is novel, and even slick.

It would be nice if there were some programming components that could do that. Well, Excel has it built in kind-of, as does Access. But nice elastic interfaces like that would be nice. (Good choice on the name for it as well.)

I can think of some immediate applications that I could use it for right now. :D

Navigation

[0] Message Index