Main Area and Open Discussion > Living Room

Bluetooth PAN Network Adapter driver.

<< < (2/2)

Stoic Joker:
Re: #2

If those NICs are using public IP addresses and this server is your DC, the short answer is you can't. You also never want to multihome a DC because it causes major problems for your network.-40hz (March 25, 2010, 10:31 AM)
--- End quote ---

That sounds awfully much like a myth to me ... If DNS is setup properly, all IPs assigned to the DC, will resolve (correctly) as the DC. I spend a lot of time with SOHO/SMB networks, and if you need to isolate services between public & private, and the budget only allows for one box. Multihoming is the safest way to do it without sending the administrative overhead through the ceiling.

This question comes up a lot. Rather than me blathering, take a look at this link. It shows a way to work around this problem.

http://social.technet.microsoft.com/Forums/en-US/winservergen/thread/1fe33392-c086-41b2-9477-27ab158d3932

Luck! :Thmbsup:
--- End quote ---

Not sure if that was the link you really wanted, but that guy is just babbling about DNS config (which granted most people do screw up), and never really answered the "Can you use 2 internet connections" question. The answer is simply yes...but you need a router with dual WAN ports to load balance the connections like this one

Public IPs assigned to (a SOHO) the DC ... :o ... Now that's scary.

40hz:
Not sure if that was the link you really wanted
-Stoic Joker (March 26, 2010, 10:06 PM)
--- End quote ---

Always a possibility. ;D

I agree that having a dual-WAN router arbitrate the two external connections will do the trick. But I didn't think that was the question being asked.

I interpreted the question to be whether it was possible to hook both the EDGE and standard broadband internet connections directly into the server and have that work reliably.

The reason I interpreted it that way was because I've seen numerous cases where a server arrives equipped with three NICs which someone decides to set up it as 2 externals + 1 internal ("to increase Internet throughput"); next plugs the external facing cards into two different internet connections, and then wonders what the problem is. Especially if (or more likely when) DNS settings are also misconfigured - usually by having the external adapter's DNS setting not point to itself and wind up having the AD 'glom' onto it as a result

And to your point about isolating services using one server with multiple interfaces, I also agree. I often do that myself. Perhaps "multihoming" wasn't the best choice of terms when I probably should have said "bridging" or "spanning" and clarified I was talking about the external network connections.

 :)


Addendum: If DNS is set up properly is a pretty big 'if' from what I've seen. FWIW I discover DNS configuration problems in about a quarter of the Windows servers I look at. What is it about server DNS settings that some people feel the need to be constantly screwing around with them?  :nono2:

 :Thmbsup:

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page